Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery

Located in the heart of Hemet, CA, Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery presents an inviting sanctuary for lovers of classic American cuisine and homemade baked delights. This beloved local gem effortlessly combines a warm, welcoming atmosphere with a diverse menu that celebrates the comforts of traditional American dining, elevated by the unmistakable charm of scratch-made pies and brunch favorites.

Step inside, and you're greeted by a clean, well-appointed dining space where friendly hosts and attentive servers set the tone for a memorable meal. The ambiance perfectly complements the menu — approachable, comforting, and crafted with care.

Polly’s culinary offerings are a delightful symphony of flavors and textures. Start your day or savor brunch with their standout Giant Cinnamon Roll French Toast, a luscious treat that melds golden, caramelized edges with a cinnamon-spiced, gooey center. For those seeking a savory balance, the Eggs Benedict is a decadent choice, enveloped in velvety hollandaise that speaks to expert preparation. Hungry guests consistently rave about the hearty Ms Polly's Triple Breakfast Surprise, a generous plate that perfectly blends eggs, sausage, and bacon into a satisfying morning feast.

No visit to Polly’s would be complete without sampling their array of pies, each slice a testament to their bakery heritage. The Strawberry Pie bursts with fresh, juicy berries nestled in a flaky crust, while the Pumpkin Pie offers a rich, spiced warmth reminiscent of home. Adventurous palates might delight in the Olallieberry Pie, celebrated by regulars for its uniquely sweet and tangy profile. The rich Key Lime Pie and creamy Coconut Cream Pie round out a dessert lineup that caters to every craving.

For lunch and dinner, the menu balances comforting staples with a touch of homestyle finesse. The Salisbury Steak with Mashed Potatoes captures the essence of hearty, satisfying American fare, as one satisfied visitor found it “very happy and satisfied.” The Chicken Fried Steak with Mashed Potatoes and Green Beans brings crispy, savory indulgence alongside classic sides, evoking a true Southern hospitality vibe. If you're looking to feed the family, the Chicken Pie Family Meal offers generous portions of flaky, savory pie that feels both nourishing and nostalgic.

Polly’s Pies also surprises with refreshing handcrafted beverages such as the zesty Strawberry Lemonade and the bright, invigorating Mimosa Sunrise, perfectly pairing with any meal to brighten your experience.

Winter visitors can cozy up to specials like the Honey Butter Pancakes, featuring two buttermilk pancakes dripping with a rich honey butter glaze and accompanied by eggs and your choice of smoked sausage or applewood smoked bacon. Equally tempting is the Honey Butter Pecan Sticky Bun, a sticky, decadent cinnamon roll with a nutty crunch—perfect for sharing, or taking home to enjoy later.

Customer experiences highlight not only the delicious food but also the attentive and caring service. From Tina’s expert menu guidance to Sarah’s diligent and warm hospitality—even on busy holidays—the staff at Polly’s Pies makes everyone feel right at home. While no restaurant is perfect, the occasional minor slip, such as a soggy pie crust or a touch too much raw onion in a salad, is swiftly forgiven in light of the overall quality and genuine care evident in every dish served.

Whether you're craving a comforting slice of pie, a savory southern-inspired entrée, or a sweet brunch treat bathed in honey glaze, Polly’s Pies Restaurant & Bakery in Hemet stands out for its authentic, heartfelt approach to American dining. It’s more than a meal—it’s a warm, satisfying experience that invites you to sit back, savor, and create memories.